Carrots work better than Sticks
January 1st, 2008Recently I was contacted by a PR rep for a service called Spinvox that I’m a big fan of and have been using for 8 months now. They solve a big problem that I had, which was that I loathed having to constantly check my voice mail. As many of you know, checking vmail quickly becomes one more Thing You Have To Do. Some of the most successful people i know routinely ask their friends to send them email since checking their personal voicemail never happens.
Spinvox changes all that.
The service affects me in two ways. First, i get an email transcription of my voicemails a few minutes after i miss a call, and since it goes to a gmail account, all my voicemail transcriptions are searchable. Second, getting the transcription lets me triage calls that i need to make and therefore i don’t always have to interrupt whatever I’m doing to take a call.
So, grateful for the free account I have (got it through techcrunch), i began researching the voicemail transcription space to get some background for my response. What i found was that many people, from the WSJ to other web entrepreneurs love the service but many of them aren’t paying for it. I took a look at their pricing model and quickly became apparent what feedback i was going to send their PR rep: Carrots work better than sticks!!
Spinvox charges 9.95/mo for 40 transcriptions and $0.45 for additional ones, Simulscribe has the same pricing for the first 40, with $0.25 for each additional one or 29.95/mo for unlimited transcriptions. Unlike most “freemium” models, this one makes me uncomfortable. Here’s why– check out my usage pattern:
December: 60 transcriptions ($9.00 additional)
November: 28 transcriptions (within plan)
October: 40 transcriptions (within plan)
September: 65 transcriptions ($11.25 additional)
August: 63 transcriptions ($10.35 additional)
This means in some months i would be going over my plan. What did this remind you of? Anyone? Cell phone plans. Which we all hate.
These services have really strong word of mouth. They can also be made viral (auto send me a transcription of my message so i see what Jim sees. You have my number after all, and I’d get to experience Spinvox for myself without having to click “Free Trial!”). However, if i know im going to waste half a buck by not picking up my phone, you can bet ill pick it up more and tell the person I’ll call back. Which means i’ll have to have some vague mental sense of how many minutes, i mean transcriptions, i have left. UReach, Spinvox’s US distribution partner, won’t let you roll over what you don’t use. Simulscribe would have me livid with thier unlimited plan once realized six months later that I’m wasting close to 20 bucks a month or 1/4th my total wireless plan cost.
Caveat: I don’t know their cost structure. But pricing plans ought to be data driven. So here’s my conclusion. If I’m a power user (I run a startup and a personal life off of this phone number) AND I’m only a few bucks above the 9.95 plan on average, who in the world is missing enough calls to justify a huge pricing plan?
At 30 bucks for unlimited messages, you leave most people wondering if being lazy is worth half the price of the average cell phone plan. People i evangelize the service to (i really do love it) tell me that it makes sense for me since i run a business but not for them since they’re benefit is one of convenience. Why would you want to have people grapple with whether they are power users?
I want to get it for my mom, but then I have to think about spending 30 bucks a month, or I have to wonder if she gets more than 40 messages a month. Why add one more thing to worry about? People should get thier voicemail transcribed and wonder where Spinvox has been all their lives rather than how many more calls they can miss before they have another fee to deal with.




